Forza Motorsport 4 Modding

I’ll save the long backstory for some other time, but basically I need to redownload my designs on a second live account. I had no issue modding credits, but the livery unlocker tool seems to be having issues I’ve never seen anywhere before.

My second profile is on the right and my primary profile is on the left. I cannot choose to open a certain group of liveries or anything of the sort, and it is the same regarding the design catalog. This ONLY applies to this specific profile, and does not seem to be an issue regarding any other profile I have. I’ll be greatly disappointed if I can’t retrieve and unlock my own designs… Suggestions…?